What Makes a Will Invalid in England and Wales?
A will may be invalid if it was improperly signed or witnessed, if the person lacked testamentary capacity or did not know and approve its contents, or if there was coercion, forgery or fraud. A validly made will can also be revoked later. If the whole will fails, check whether an earlier valid will still applies. If none does, the intestacy rules apply.
If the will’s validity remains disputed, the court can decide it in a probate claim.
Which describes your situation?
I'm an executor facing a challenge
Keep the original will and relevant records safe. Check whether a grant has been issued and get advice before distributing assets if there is a material dispute.
I'm questioning a will
Identify the will and the change that concerns you. Write down what you know first-hand and find out whether probate has been granted.
What happens if a will is invalid?
If the whole will fails, an earlier valid will may apply if it was never effectively revoked. Check each will and codicil, along with any separate act of revocation. For example, if the deceased made an earlier will and then married, the marriage may already have revoked that earlier will. A problem with the later will would then leave no earlier will to fall back on.
If no valid will applies, the intestacy rules determine who inherits. The person entitled to administer the estate may also change. If only one gift or provision fails, the rest of the will can still take effect. Check what the will says about failed gifts and the remainder of the estate. Intestacy may apply to any part that the will leaves undisposed of.
What can make a will invalid or stop it taking effect?
1. Signing or witnessing problems
Under section 9 of the Wills Act 1837, the will must be in writing and the will-maker must intend the signature to give effect to it. They can sign it themselves or direct someone to sign in their presence. The will-maker must make or acknowledge the signature with both witnesses present together. Each witness must attest and sign, or acknowledge their signature, in the will-maker’s presence. The witnesses can do that separately.
What to check first. Who was there at each stage and what did each witness see? Keep the original if you have it and record the witnesses’ names. If it was witnessed by live video, check the date. The temporary remote-witnessing rule applied to wills made from 31 January 2020 to 31 January 2024 inclusive.
2. Lack of testamentary capacity
The test in Banks v Goodfellow asks whether the person understood what making a will meant, the broad extent of their property and the claims they ought to consider, and whether a disorder of mind distorted their choices. The assessment concerns the particular will and the relevant time. A diagnosis of dementia alone does not establish lack of capacity.
What to check first. What did the drafter record about the person’s understanding when taking instructions and when the will was signed? Compare those notes with dated medical evidence and first-hand observations. Where instructions and signing were some time apart, put both dates on the chronology.
3. Lack of knowledge and approval
A person with capacity still needs to understand and approve the contents of the will they sign. If a beneficiary arranged the appointments or supplied instructions, check what happened between those instructions and the final signing.
What to check first. Did the will-maker give or confirm their wishes independently? Who explained the final version and what arrangements helped them understand it if, for example, they had difficulty reading it?
4. Undue influence
Undue influence in this context means coercion that overbore the will-maker’s free wishes. A close relationship, dependence on a carer or a sudden change in the will can give you questions to ask. The person alleging undue influence must prove coercion.
What to check first. What did the person accused of pressure actually do, when did it happen and how could it have affected this gift or this will? Look for dated messages, independent accounts and any explanation the will-maker gave at the time.
5. Forgery or fraud
Forgery concerns whether a signature or document is genuine. Fraud can include knowingly or recklessly making false statements about a potential beneficiary that cause the will-maker to exclude them or reduce their gift.
What to check first. For a disputed signature, identify who kept the original, who saw it signed and whether there are genuine signatures from around the same time. An expert opinion may help. For alleged deception, identify exactly what was said, who said it and what evidence links it to the change.
6. Revocation
A will can be revoked by a later will, by a properly executed written revocation or by destruction with the intention to revoke. Marriage or forming a civil partnership also generally revokes a will. An important exception is where the will shows that the person expected to marry or form a civil partnership with a particular person and intended the will to survive that event.
What to check first. Put every will, codicil and relevant marriage or civil partnership on one timeline. If the original is missing, find out who last had it and what evidence there is about how it was lost or destroyed. In some cases an original that has been lost can be proved using a copy or other evidence.
What if the problem is something else?
- Is a will invalid if the executor dies? No. A surviving executor may be able to act. If none can act, check who is entitled to administer the estate under the will.
- A witness receives a gift. The will can still be valid, but a gift to an attesting witness or their spouse or civil partner will normally fail.
- The will seems unfair. Eligible family members or dependants may have a separate claim for reasonable financial provision. See our guide to Inheritance Act claims.
- The will is unclear or contains a mistake. Interpretation or rectification may be the right route. See our guide to unclear wording and drafting mistakes.
- There was a divorce or civil partnership dissolution. The will generally continues to operate. Gifts and appointments for the former spouse or civil partner usually take effect as though that person had died on the date of the divorce or dissolution, unless the will shows a contrary intention.
Financial provision and rectification normally have a six-month limit from the relevant first grant of representation. A later application needs the court’s permission.
What should you do first?
- Check whether probate has been granted. Note the will date, the date of any grant and any formal papers or deadlines. If there is a genuine dispute about validity or entitlement and the grant has yet to issue, a probate caveat may be appropriate. It generally stops a grant from issuing while it is effective. If you have already been served with a warning, see the guide to responding to a caveat warning.
- Preserve what you have. Keep the complete will and codicils, plus relevant letters and messages. If you hold the original, leave it as it is. Write a short dated note of what you remember and identify where other records are held.
- Ask for the evidence that could change the next step. If the concern is how the will was made, a focused Larke v Nugus request can ask the drafter about instructions, preparation and signing. If the only question is who saw the signature, start with the witnesses and the signing record.
Example: a late change to the will
Illustration. A daughter says her brother pressured their mother to change her will shortly before she died. He booked the appointment and received a larger share. The useful first question is what happened at the appointment. A contemporaneous note of the mother meeting the drafter alone, explaining the change and rejecting a suggestion would inform the next decision. If the file instead shows the brother gave the instructions and remained in the room, ask how the drafter checked the mother’s own wishes before deciding what further evidence to seek.
Who decides if a will is invalid?
Information and negotiation can narrow or resolve a concern. If validity stays in dispute, the court can decide it in a probate claim. The burden of proof depends on the ground and the evidence. A will that appears duly executed can carry a presumption of proper signing, while a genuine dispute about the signature may require the person relying on the will to prove due execution.
Can probate be granted on an invalid will?
Yes. A defect can come to light after probate has been granted. In some circumstances a registrar or district judge can revoke an existing grant under rule 41 of the Non-Contentious Probate Rules. Take advice promptly if the estate has already been distributed or distribution is imminent. Delay can prejudice or, in some circumstances, bar a validity challenge. In proceedings, the court has discretion over costs and may order the unsuccessful party to pay some of the other side’s costs.
Help with a will dispute
If you’re an executor facing a challenge, we can review the allegation and evidence, identify what needs checking and help prepare a focused response where appropriate. We agree the work and fixed fee before starting. If you want written advice first, our optional Dispute Assessment & Action Plan costs £480 including VAT.
If you’re questioning a will, tell us what concerns you, how the outcome affects you and whether probate has been granted. We’ll let you know whether we can help.
General information about estates in England and Wales. Obtain advice on your own circumstances.