Skip to main content
Practice guide | Questions about a will

Larke v Nugus Letters: Making a Request and Responding

Last reviewed: 2 November 2026

Have you been surprised by the contents of a will, or are you an executor dealing with questions about how it was made?

A Larke v Nugus letter asks the will drafter for information about the instructions, preparation and signing of the will. The reply can explain what happened, clarify concerns and help you decide what to do next.

This guide is for people seeking information about how a will was made, and executors or will drafters responding to those enquiries.

I have concerns about a will

Find out what to ask, what records may help and how to assess the reply.

Making a request →

I am an executor

Understand the enquiry, your role and the steps to take with the will drafter.

Responding to questions →

I Have Concerns About a Will: Where Do I Start?

A late change, an unexpected beneficiary’s involvement or uncertainty about the signing may raise questions. Disappointment with an inheritance does not itself show that a will is invalid; identify the particular facts you want explained.

1. Identify the will and your interest

Record the date of the will, any earlier will or codicil you know about, your relationship to the deceased and how the outcome may affect you. Establish whether a Grant has been issued and retain any formal correspondence.

2. Set out the concern clearly

Prepare a short chronology. Separate what you saw or heard yourself from what others reported and what remains uncertain. Identify who holds relevant documents without altering originals or encouraging witnesses to agree an account.

3. Ask focused questions

The questions should follow the concern. Use the illustrative question checklist below to identify the facts you need explained. A targeted request is more useful than a list of allegations unsupported by facts.

4. Review the reply before deciding the next step

Compare the answers with available records. A reply may resolve the concern or identify gaps needing follow-up. It is evidence to assess, rather than a court decision that the will is valid or invalid.

For the different grounds and evidence involved, see our guide to questions about a will’s validity.

What questions should a Larke v Nugus request include?

Select questions relevant to the concern about this will. An illustrative checklist is:

  • Instructions: when and how were instructions received, and who took them?
  • People involved: who attended meetings or communicated instructions, and what contact did the drafter have directly with the person making the will?
  • Changes: what changes from an earlier will were discussed, and what reasons were recorded?
  • Explanation and understanding: how were the contents explained and the person’s understanding assessed?
  • The particular concern: what contemporaneous notes or other records address the capacity, pressure or other issue being raised?
  • Signing: who was present, who witnessed the will and what were the signing arrangements?

Use this to frame a focused enquiry rather than sending every question unchanged. When assessing a reply, distinguish records made at the time from later recollection. Disclosure and authority still need consideration, as explained in the executor section below.

Need GP or hospital notes as well as the drafter’s account? Read obtaining and understanding the deceased’s medical records, including access rights, missing information and how we can help.

What is a Larke v Nugus statement?

A Larke v Nugus statement is the will drafter’s written account of how the will was prepared and signed, given in reply to a Larke v Nugus request. It is usually prepared by the solicitor or will writer who took the instructions, from their file and their recollection.

A useful statement normally covers:

  • how long the drafter had known the person making the will, and who introduced them;
  • when and how instructions were given, who was present and whether anyone else passed on instructions;
  • what the person said about changes from an earlier will, and any reasons recorded;
  • any assessment of capacity, including whether a medical opinion was obtained;
  • how the will was explained to the person and approved by them; and
  • who was present at signing, who witnessed the will and how it was signed.

The statement should make clear which answers come from notes made at the time and which come from later memory. Copies of the relevant file notes are often provided with it. It is not sworn evidence and does not decide whether the will is valid, but it is often the most important early evidence about how the will was made.

Need help preparing a request or reviewing a reply? See how we can help →

I Am an Executor: How Should I Handle the Enquiry?

A request is not proof that the will is invalid. A measured response can establish what is disputed and whether information will help resolve it.

1. Preserve the records

Keep the will, earlier versions, correspondence and relevant messages. Ask the drafter to preserve the preparation file. Record the Grant position and any deadline in formal papers.

2. Clarify who is being asked to do what

Identify the will and concerns raised. A request for the drafter’s account is different from a demand for the executor to answer from personal knowledge. Ask for clarification where the request is unclear.

3. Liaise with the drafter about disclosure

Confidentiality and legal privilege survive death, but established probate principles can permit appropriate disclosure. Check the authority and scope with the drafter; neither release of the entire file nor refusal of all information should be assumed appropriate. Executor consent is not the only possible basis for disclosure.

4. Keep your role clear

If you are also a beneficiary, distinguish your administration responsibilities from your personal interest. Obtain advice on an appropriate response before committing estate funds to a contested position. Your role may require investigation rather than simply defending the will.

The Law Society’s disputed-wills guidance explains the relevant disclosure considerations.

What Do Larke v Nugus and Addison v Niaz Show?

Larke v Nugus

In Larke v Nugus, the Court of Appeal took account of the failure to provide information about the will when deciding costs, even though the challenge failed. The practical lesson is that a constructive exchange of relevant information may avoid unnecessary proceedings. See the Law Society’s explanation of the decision.

Addison v Niaz [2024] EWHC 3124 (Fam)

The court criticised prolonged delay and an inadequate response from the will drafter and ordered her to pay the applicants’ costs of the application. A reply should address the actual questions and distinguish records made at the time from later recollection. The outcome depended on the facts; a late or incomplete reply does not automatically invalidate a will or produce a costs order. Read the judgment.

How long should I wait for a Larke v Nugus reply?

The appropriate response period depends on the request, the availability of the file and the work needed to review it. Ask for an acknowledgement and a realistic timetable. If more time is needed, ask why and when the substantive reply is expected; do not assume that silence proves anything about the will.

What if the reply is late or incomplete?

Identify the unanswered questions and ask what further information or records can be supplied. Distinguish an explanation that is missing from a disagreement with an answer already given.

A focused follow-up is usually more useful than repeatedly sending the same demand. Identify what remains missing and whether further enquiries are proportionate to their likely value and cost.

Keep separate deadlines in view

A pending request does not suspend legal deadlines, stop a Grant being issued or replace a response to a caveat warning. A claim for financial provision under the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975 is distinct from a will-validity challenge: the usual time limit is six months from the first grant of representation, and a later application requires the court’s permission. Read section 4.

How much does a Larke v Nugus request cost?

Human Law’s fee

The work may involve preparing a request, reviewing a reply or helping with a response. See our services and fees.

A charge proposed by the will drafter

Any charge for preparing a response, reviewing the file or supplying copies is separate from Human Law’s fee. Clarify the proposed amount, its basis, the work covered and who is expected to pay before incurring costs. Do not assume the estate will automatically meet it. The Law Society’s disputed-wills guidance addresses disclosure and charging considerations.

Help with a will-drafter enquiry

We can prepare a focused Larke v Nugus request, review a reply and identify useful follow-up questions, or help an executor or will drafter prepare a response.

Send a free enquiry →

Related Guidance

General information about estates in England and Wales. The appropriate advice depends on your documents, circumstances and any applicable deadline.

About Justin →