Trust Disputes and Trustee Deadlock
Short answer: When accounts are missing, trustees cannot agree or a family trust decision is stalled, establish what the trust allows, what information is needed and the next practical step. A focused request, a decision proposal or negotiation may help move matters forward.
Who this is for. Trustees and beneficiaries involved in family trust disputes in England and Wales, including will trusts and trusts created during someone’s lifetime.
More detail
Which family trusts can we help with?
The family trusts we cover
We consider life-interest, discretionary and bare trusts, trusts for children and family property held under an express trust deed. These descriptions can overlap. The trust document, governing law, parties and particular problem determine suitability. Vulnerable-beneficiary matters are assessed individually where capacity, benefits or Court of Protection issues may require specialist input.
Trustee, beneficiary or both: the role we advise on
Advice for your particular role
We agree whom we advise and in what capacity. Advice to one trustee is distinct from advice to the trustees jointly or to a beneficiary.
If you are both a trustee and a beneficiary, identify both roles at the outset. Your responsibilities as trustee and your personal interests may need separate consideration.
Work that can be agreed
Further work by agreement
Separately agreed work may include:
- An accounts request, review of a reply or trustee response, with the core documents and reply allowance specified.
- A focused decision letter, information-exchange proposal or arrangement for expenditure and future decisions.
- Defined negotiations or preparation for mediation.
- Assessment of a consensual trustee change, with implementation separately scoped.
- Where another specialist is needed, a chronology, evidence summary and issues note for the handover.
If you want a separate written review of the options first, the Dispute Assessment & Action Plan is optional.
Common questions about trust disputes
Can a trust be challenged?
It depends what is being challenged. Some disputes question whether the trust is valid at all, for example whether the person creating it had capacity or was pressured. Far more often, the disagreement is about how the trust is being run: missing information, a decision the trustees will not make, or how a property is used. Those problems can often be resolved by asking for the right information and negotiating a practical decision. When trustees cannot agree →
What can I do if I am unhappy with my trustee?
Identify the specific concern: a missing account, a delayed decision, how money has been spent or how requests have been handled. Put focused questions to the trustees in writing and keep a record of the replies. Trustees must act in line with the trust deed and in the beneficiaries’ interests, and a clear, specific request is harder to ignore than general criticism. Trust accounts and information →
Do trustees have to give beneficiaries information?
Beneficiaries can usually expect information about the trust and how it is being managed, such as accounts and details of the trust property. What a particular beneficiary can see depends on their interest and the document requested. Trustees are not normally required to give reasons for discretionary decisions. What a beneficiary can ask for →
Can a trustee be replaced?
Often, yes. A trustee may agree to retire, the trust deed may give someone power to appoint new trustees and, in some cases, the beneficiaries together can direct a change. Whether a consensual change is available depends on the deed and the people involved. Retirement and replacement →
General information for England and Wales. The trust’s terms and individual circumstances determine the advice.