Can a Probate Caveat Lead to a Personal Costs Order?
Last reviewed: 21 October 2026
Yes. A probate dispute involving a caveat can lead to a personal costs order. Liability is not automatic: the procedure, evidence and parties’ conduct matter.
The small fee for entering a caveat does not measure the financial exposure of maintaining it or responding to it. This guide is for both caveators and executors assessing what the next decision could cost.
Route 1: assess who should pay your legal fees
No. The existence of an estate fund does not guarantee that either party can charge their dispute costs to it. An executor’s entitlement to reimbursement depends on the capacity in which they act and whether the expenditure was properly incurred. Fighting over their own inheritance is different from properly administering the estate.
Probate costs can require a nuanced decision. In Marley v Rawlings (Costs) [2014] UKSC 51, the Supreme Court considered reasonable competing positions and a solicitor’s mistake, ultimately ordering the solicitor’s insurers to pay the parties’ costs on the terms explained in the judgment. That was not a caveat-removal decision, and it establishes no general promise that an estate or insurer will fund a dispute.
CPR 57.7(5) contains a particular costs protection for a defendant who gives the prescribed notice requiring proof of a will without raising a positive case. It is qualified by the absence of reasonable grounds for opposition. It is not blanket protection for entering a caveat.
In Elliott v Simmonds [2016] EWHC 962 (Ch), the court ordered costs against the opponent of the will from the point when sufficient material was available to assess whether there were reasonable grounds for opposition. This followed substantive probate proceedings; it was not an automatic penalty for entering a caveat or an order against the person issuing the warning.
Route 2: understand possible personal costs liability
For Registry applications dealt with on summons, NCPR rule 63 gives the Registrar power to decide who pays costs and to what extent. In contentious probate litigation, CPR Part 44 provides the general costs framework.
The court considers the circumstances, including whether issues were reasonably pursued, conduct before and during proceedings, settlement offers and engagement with appropriate dispute resolution. Losing a case is not the only consideration; nor does a genuine initial concern justify maintaining the same position indefinitely.
For example, relevant questions may include whether a person continued an unsupported allegation after receiving material evidence, caused avoidable procedural work or refused a reasonable opportunity to narrow the dispute.
An order for costs is not necessarily reimbursement of the whole bill. The amount and basis of assessment matter. Do not assume indemnity costs, or a particular sum, merely because someone describes the caveat as “wrong”.
Route 3: distinguish delay expenses from recoverable loss
Illustration only. An empty estate property incurs recurring costs of £550 a month. Over four months, that is £2,200. The parties are also considering a quoted £3,500 including VAT for a defined legal step.
Those figures help them assess proportionality. They do not prove that the caveator owes £5,700. Some property costs might have arisen anyway; the legal quote is not a court award; and responsibility, causation and any right to recovery need separate examination.
Keep actual invoices, dates and reasons for delay. Distinguish unavoidable administration time from additional delay attributed to the dispute. Use the carrying-cost calculator to organise estimates, not to calculate someone’s legal liability.
Route 4: distinguish compensation from legal costs
A separate compensation claim alleges that legally actionable conduct caused a recoverable loss. An adverse costs order does not itself award damages for all delay.
A letter threatening “all costs and losses” may combine these categories. Ask which legal basis, expense, period and remedy are actually relied upon.
What Should Each Side Gather Before Spending More?
- The will, relevant entitlement and the precise objection to the Grant.
- The caveat record, warning, service evidence, Appearance, summons and any order.
- A dated record of information requested, supplied and still missing.
- Actual estate bills, proposed legal fees and any offer to resolve the issue.
- A clear objective for the next step and the evidence it is expected to establish.
For the executor’s initial response and Justin’s video on warning decisions, read the caveats guide. Do not make unsupported threats that all estate losses will automatically be recovered personally.
General information for estates in England and Wales, not advice on an individual matter. For a live deadline, issued proceedings or an immediate asset risk, obtain prompt appropriate advice; do not wait for an assessment.